Skip to content
  • Gestoras
  • Fundos
  • Ideias
  • Institucional
  • OffShore
Menu
  • Gestoras
  • Fundos
  • Ideias
  • Institucional
  • OffShore

IDEIAS

Are High Yield Investors Getting Properly Paid for Default Risk?

  • Sem categoria
  • 17/08/2022

Link para o artigo original : https://www.lordabbett.com/en-us/institutional-investor/insights/markets-and-economy/are-high-yield-investors-getting-properly-paid-for-default-risk-.html

 

Are High Yield Investors Getting Properly Paid for Default Risk?

Amid a softening U.S. economy, investors may be wondering about prospective default rates—and their potential impact on credit spreads.

 

By  Riz Hussain   Product Messaging Lead
Fixed-income market participants often like to distill bond investing into a series of logical math problems. But there are elements of discretion and art as well that go into approaching many of the questions they are looking to answer. One good example is the current debate around two key questions:1. What default rate is priced into U.S. credit?2. Are investors being properly compensated for that risk?These questions are relevant for many reasons, including the uptick in defaults likely to come amid the expected deceleration of economic activity and global central-bank tightening. They are simple questions on the surface. But the broad topic is one that relies on a range of assumptions and interpretations of the questions themselves. To answer, we must first review what constitutes a credit spread.We know that an all-encompassing credit spread above a risk-free benchmark rate is meant to compensate investors for two risk categories: loss given the possibility of default and, broadly, all other risks like portfolio liquidity, potential capital structure and operational changes, future issuance that could subordinate existing creditors, etc. We have some definitive math to approximate the first, but it’s more of a subjective exercise for the latter, which we’ll call the ‘excess spread’. (For additional background, please see our June 2021 whitepaper, “Understanding Two Key Dimensions of Credit Spreads.PDF Document”)

How the Distress Ratio Guides Default Expectations

It makes sense to first hunt for one-year-forward default candidates from those credits that are already exhibiting some level of distress in current valuations. Credit investors commonly track the percentage of the high yield market with an option-adjusted spread above 1000 basis points (bp), otherwise known as the ‘distress ratio’.
  • As of July month-end, the U.S. high yield distress ratio was 8.1%, rising from just below 2% at the start of the year (see Figure 1). However, this measure improved over the course of the month by 2.6 percentage points, as you would expect, given the overall rally in high yield credit spreads during July.
  • In our prior referenced work above, we found that the median ratio of the actual 12-month-forward default rate to the starting distress ratio was about 36%. We can’t definitively state all defaults over a coming year come from those credits identified as under distress during that period, but academic work published elsewhere notes that the vast majority of defaulting names are indeed trading at distressed valuations within the year prior.
  • So, if we just use that experience as a guide, and if the distress ratio did not change from the levels on July 29, it suggests an estimated 12-month-forward default rate of about 2.9% (=36%*8.1%). Right now, that’s about the mid- to upper-end of the range of what most sell-side analysts have been calling for in high yield.  Recall that the U.S. high yield, trailing-12-month default rate hit a COVID-19-era peak of about 6% in late 2020.
  • Using 40% as the approximate long-term, average observed recovery rate on defaulted high yield bonds, and the current market starting price of approximately $90, imply an expected loss-given default of 1.45%, favorable relative to current spread levels

Figure 1. Tracking the U.S. High Yield Distress Ratio

Distress measures (as defined) for the U.S. high yield market as of July 31, 2022
Line Chart
Source: ICE BofA US High Yield Index and ICE BofA US Distressed Index. Data as of July 31, 2022. LHS=left-hand side of chart. RHS=right-hand side of chart. In this context, “distressed” refers to issues with an option-adjusted spread of 1,000 basis points (each basis point is one-one hundredth of a percentage point). Past performance is not a reliable indicator or guarantee of future results.  Due to market volatility, the asset classes depicted in this chart may not perform in a similar manner in the future. For illustrated purposes only and does not represent any specific portfolio managed by Lord Abbett or any particular investment. Indexes are unmanaged, do not reflect the deduction of fees or expenses, and are not available for direct investment.
As the discussion above may imply, coming up with a reasonably accurate, top-down, derived estimate on default-loss pricing at any one point in time depends on a range of factors and assumptions. Short of a full discussion here, in prior publications, we’ve pointed to the strong starting point of U.S. high yield credit metrics today, and the belief that corporate balance sheets are well positioned to counter the margin deterioration and adverse turn in credit metrics that would be expected in a softening U.S. economy. Further, we don’t see specific at-risk sectors in the market today, unlike the weakness in energy leading to the commodity crisis of 2015-2016, which tells us defaults may be more focused on a narrower set of idiosyncratic risk stories in the coming years. That contrasts with the broader weakness of the credit markets in some of the recent default cycles.

The “Excess Spread” Available in U.S. High Yield

Given a range of potential default-loss outcomes, how are investors being compensated? Positive values that fall out for an assessment of this “excess spread” would reflect our long-standing view that credit spreads overpay investors for defaults. That outcome would also emphasize that investors embrace a strategic mindset (over a “market timing” approach) and collect this excess spread that remains after absorbing default losses. These positive values for excess spread are essentially risk premium that patient investors can capture, after adjusting current spread for future default losses. And it varies given investors’ collective risk sentiment, tolerance, holding periods, market structure liquidity, etc.  However, we can argue that at any point in time, the then-current credit spread of the broad investment-grade-credit corporate market could serve as a lower bound for the excess spread in high yield, given investment-grade credit is largely a default-risk-remote asset class with similar types of non-default risk as high yield.

In Figure 2, we show the excess spread based on a range of assumptions for the recovery rate and default rate, at the current Index option-adjusted spread (OAS) and price (+485 bps and $90.28, respectively). Note that except for a combination of particularly low recovery levels and/or high default rates that largely exceeded that of the COVID-19 pandemic, investors are collecting a positive risk premium that exceeds the OAS of the investment-grade market at today’s valuations. Focusing just on a default assumption of approximately 3% (in line with the estimate derived from the distress ratio) and a 40% recovery leads to an excess spread of 318 bps today, for example.

Figure 2. Excess Spread on High Yield Based on Assumed Recovery and Default Rates

Excess spread in high yield market based on assumptions of option-adjusted spread of 485 basis points and an issue price of $90.28 (actual 7/31/2022 values)
Chart
Source: Lord Abbett. Data as of July 31, 2022.
For illustrative purposes only and does not represent any specific portfolio managed by Lord Abbett or any particular investment. Indexes are unmanaged, do not reflect the deduction of fees or expenses, and are not available for direct investment.
Past performance is not a reliable indicator or guarantee of future results. 

 

Further, when some investors ask what default rate is being priced into the market, in reality, they may largely be asking for a worst-case scenario where the assumed excess spread is 0 bps. As shown in Figure 3, around current valuations and a recovery of 40%, the implied default rate is north of 8%, over twice as high as suggested by the distress ratio and a range of third-party estimates in the marketplace today.

Figure 3. Investors Appear to Be Overly Pessimistic about Potential Default Rates

Implied default rate based on assumptions of option-adjusted spread of 485 basis points and an issue price of $90.28 (actual 7/31/2022 values) and no excess spread
Chart
Source: Lord Abbett. Data as of July 31, 2022.
For illustrative purposes only and does not represent any specific portfolio managed by Lord Abbett or any particular investment. Indexes are unmanaged, do not reflect the deduction of fees or expenses, and are not available for direct investment.
Past performance is not a reliable indicator or guarantee of future results. 

Key Takeaways

So how should we respond to the simple question, “What default rate is priced into the U.S. high yield market?” The answer is, “It depends.” But today’s spread levels provide a good deal of excess spread even under dire default and recovery assumptions. There is plenty of uncertainty around the variables in the excess-spread calculation in any given year. That complexity offers a compelling reason to adopt a strategic, and actively managed approach to collecting income in leveraged credit, one that has the proven potential to provide investors with consistently attractive compensation for assuming default risk over multiple years.

Under the Hood of “Excess Spread”

We discuss excess spread, the amount that high yield investors can capture in excess of projected default loss, extensively in this article. But how is it derived? First, let’s start with two equations that are important in credit math:

Spread Compensation for Expected Defaults = (Index Option-Adjusted Spread [OAS] – Excess Spread)
Expected Loss Given Default = Default Rate * [(Index Price – Recovery)/Index Price]

And we know by definition:

Spread Compensation for Expected Defaults = Expected Loss Given Default

Thus:

(Index OAS – Excess Spread) = Default Rate * [(Index Price – Recovery)/Index Price], or
(Index OAS – Excess Spread) = Default Rate * (1 – Recovery/Index Price)

Determining all these factors leads us to our excess spread calculation:

Excess Spread = Index OAS – (Default Rate * (1 – Recovery/Index Price))


As informações aqui contidas estão sendo fornecidas pela GAMA Investimentos (“Distribuidor”), na qualidade de distribuidora do site. O conteúdo deste documento [e informações neste site] contém informações proprietárias sobre LORD ABBETT e o Fundo. Nenhuma parte deste documento nem as informações proprietárias do LORD ABBETT ou DO Fundo aqui podem ser (i) copiadas, fotocopiadas ou duplicadas de qualquer forma por qualquer meio (ii) distribuídas sem o consentimento prévio por escrito do LORD ABBETT. Divulgações importantes estão incluídas ao longo deste documento e que devem ser utilizadas exclusivamente para fins de análise do LORD ABBETT e do Fundo. Este documento não pretende ser totalmente compreendido ou conter todas as informações que o destinatário possa desejar ao analisar o LORD ABBETT e o Fundo e/ou seus respectivos produtos gerenciados ou futuramente gerenciados. Este material não pode ser utilizado como base para qualquer decisão de investimento. O destinatário deve confiar exclusivamente nos documentos constitutivos de qualquer produto e em sua própria análise independente. Nem o LORD ABBETT nem o Fundo estão registrados ou licenciados no Brasil e o Fundo não está disponível para venda pública no Brasil. Embora a Gama e suas afiliadas acreditem que todas as informações aqui contidas sejam precisas, nenhuma delas faz qualquer declaração ou garantia quanto à conclusão ou necessidades dessas informações.

Essas informações podem conter declarações de previsões que envolvem riscos e incertezas; os resultados reais podem diferir materialmente de quaisquer expectativas, projeções ou previsões feitas ou inferidas em tais declarações de previsões. Portanto, os destinatários são advertidos a não depositar confiança indevida nessas declarações de previsões. As projeções e/ou valores futuros de investimentos não realizados dependerão, entre outros fatores, dos resultados operacionais futuros, do valor dos ativos e das condições de mercado no momento da alienação, restrições legais e contratuais à transferência que possam limitar a liquidez, quaisquer custos de transação e prazos e forma de venda, que podem diferir das premissas e circunstâncias em que se baseiam as perspectivas atuais, e muitas das quais são difíceis de prever. O desempenho passado não é indicativo de resultados futuros.

PrevAnterior
PróximoNext
Compartilhe:

Receba nossos conteúdos

Cadastre-se abaixo e receba conteúdos exclusivos.

quero me cadastrar

Política de Gestão do Risco Operacional

Política de Responsabilidade Socioambiental

Política de Gerenciamento de Risco de Liquidez

Declaração de Inaplicabilidade de Política de Rateio de Ordens

Política de Investimentos Pessoais

Política de Tratamento de Conflitos de Interesse e Segregação de Atividades e Funções

Formulário de Referência

Manual de Ética e Conduta

Manual de Compliance

Formulário de Fundos ASG

Política de Voto

Política de Gestão de Riscos

Entre em contato:

+55 11 5242-9000
info@gamainvestimentos.com.br

São Paulo

Av. Brg. Faria Lima, 4300 – CJ 22
Itaim Bibi – 04538-132

CANAL DE DENÚNCIAS EXTERNO

Nós da Gama Investimentos buscamos atender nossos clientes e atuar internamente da forma mais transparente e ética possível. Por isso, criamos um canal exclusivo para denúncias, sugestões ou reclamações, para todo e qualquer assunto, inerente à Gama Investimentos, no qual o contactante deseje maior sigilo em sua comunicação e acesso direto a nossa área de controles e Compliance. Assim, o canal de denúncias configura-se como uma maneira segura e confidencial de relatar toda e qualquer forma de descumprimento legal, normativo ou, ainda, de políticas e códigos previamente constituídos na estrutura de conduta ética e de cultura de integridade e boas práticas da nossa empresa. Para acesso a esse canal, disponibilizamos a caixa de e-mail do denuncia@gamainvestimentos.com.br, para reporte.

© 2025 Gama Investimentos. Todos os direitos reservados.
  • Institucional
  • Gestoras
  • Fundos
  • Ideias
  • Como Investir
  • Contato
  • Compliance
  • FAQ
  • Gama Carreira
  • Na Mídia
  • Institucional
  • Gestoras
  • Fundos
  • Ideias
  • Como Investir
  • Contato
  • Compliance
  • FAQ
  • Gama Carreira
  • Na Mídia

Termos de aceite para o formulário de cadastro da Newsletter

Os dados pessoais coletados através deste website poderão ser tratados pela Gama Investimentos Ltda (“GAMA”) para compartilhamento de informações institucionais e dos seus fundos de investimento sob gestão através da nossa mailing list, sendo mantidos arquivados pelo prazo mínimo de 5 anos em cumprimento à regulação.

A GAMA está empenhada em salvaguardar a privacidade de seus clientes e usuários que visitam nosso website e adota uma série de recursos tecnológicos para a manutenção da privacidade dos dados que coleta, protegendo seus arquivos e sistemas contra acessos não autorizados e vazamentos. Qualquer solicitação de informação sobre o tratamento de dados pessoais pela GAMA poderá ser feita através do e-mail do encarregado: info@gamainvestimentos.com.br.”

Ao responder com seus dados cadastrais você concorda com o tratamento deles para a finalidade acima mencionada, sendo garantido o direito de revogar o presente consentimento a qualquer tempo mediante envio de pedido ao Encarregado.

Terms of acceptance for the newsletter registration form

Personal data collected through this website may be processed by Gama Investimentos Ltda (“GAMA”) for the purpose of sharing institutional information and information on its investment funds under management through our mailing list and will be kept on file for a minimum period of 5 years in compliance with regulations.

GAMA is committed to safeguarding the privacy of its clients and website users and adopts a range of technological measures to maintain the privacy of the data it collects, protecting its files and systems against unauthorized access and leaks. Any request for information about the processing of personal data by GAMA may be made through the email of the Data Protection Officer: info@gamainvestimentos.com.br.”

By providing your personal data, you agree to its processing for the aforementioned purpose, and you have the right to revoke this consent at any time by sending a request to the Data Protection Officer.

Este site utiliza cookies para aprimorar sua experiência, ou seja, armazenamos dados para análise e para produção de conteúdo adaptado ao seu interesse. Ao clicar em "Aceito" você concorda em armazenar cookies em seu dispositivo. Para saber mais, leia nossa Política de privacidade.Aceito